昨(zuó)天我(wǒ)談到了res ipsa loquitur,借著(zhe)今天套(tào)用IRAC模式呈現一(yī)首法律情詩。
Love v. Res Ipsa Loquitur
Issue: How can I prove that I love you?
Rule: The doctrine of res ipsa loquitur requires the plaintiff to show that the accident causing the injury is a type that would not normally occur unless someone was negligent and the negligence is probably attributable to the defendant. The plaintiff can still lose, however, if the inference of negligence is rejected by the trier of fact.
Analysis: If I assert that I love you, I need not to prove it. Because it is res ipsa loquitur, that is, I would not normally hold such rich and complex feelings unless I loved you, but it is unfortunate for me that res ipsa loquitur is merely a permissible reference, the power of permissibility belongs to you, the trier of fact, and if you abuse your power and reject my claim, I would fail.
Conclusion: Res ipsa loquitur is inefficient to prove that I love you, I should produce more evidence to support my claim.
愛與自證
如果我主張我愛你
我根本不需要證明它
因為這是一種事實自證
也就是(shì)說
除非我愛你
否則我不會出奇的擁有如此(cǐ)豐富且多元(yuán)的感受
然而
這對於我來說(shuō)是可(kě)悲的
事實自證僅僅是一種可經允許的推理
你以一個事實審判(pàn)者的姿態
擁(yōng)有允許權
如果(guǒ)你濫用(yòng)你的(de)權力(lì)並駁回我的訴求
我(wǒ)將敗訴
事實(shí)自證是不充分的
我仍(réng)將需要(yào)提供更多的證據
證明(míng)我愛你(nǐ)
作者介(jiè)紹
延彬彬律師
現為上海(hǎi)律宏律師事務所合夥人律(lǜ)師,民革黨員。先後被評(píng)為(wéi)民革上海市委三八紅旗手、民革普陀區委先進個人,並在第一屆上海律師學術大賽中獲(huò)“代理詞評選(xuǎn)”優(yōu)秀獎(jiǎng),持有證券從業資格(gé)證、上海市知(zhī)識產權工(gōng)作者證等。
執業領(lǐng)域:
不良(liáng)資產處(chù)置(zhì),企業法律顧問,各類合同糾紛,勞動人事糾紛,婚姻家庭(tíng)糾紛的處理,刑事案件以及(jí)行政案件的處理,醫療器械行業法律服務等。
執業理念:
每個人都值得(dé)擁(yōng)有自己的私人律師(shī)。
微信:
w13764304810